Rating: 7 out of 10
Summary: In a small town outside Istanbul, Sinan Basioglu, a devout Muslim, and his wife, Nilüfer, are preparing for their nine-year-old son’s coming-of-age ceremony. Their headstrong fifteen-year-old daughter, İrem, resents the attention her brother, Ismail, receives from their parents. For her, there was no such festive observance–only the wrapping of her head in a dark scarf and strict rules that keep her hidden away from boys and her friends. But even before the night of the celebration, İrem has started to change, to the dismay of her Kurdish father. What Sinan doesn’t know is that much of her transformation is due to her secret relationship with their neighbor, Dylan, the seventeen-year-old American son of expatriate teachers.
İrem sees Dylan as the gateway to a new life, one that will free her from the confines of conservative Islam. Yet the young man’s presence and Sinan’s growing awareness of their relationship affirms Sinan’s wish to move his family to the safety of his old village, a place where his children would be sheltered from the cosmopolitan temptations of Istanbul, and where, as the civil war in the south wanes, he hopes to raise his children in the Kurdish tradition.
But when a massive earthquake hits in the middle of the night, the Basioglu family is faced with greater challenges. Losing everything, they are forced to forage for themselves, living as refugees in their own country. Their survival becomes dependent on their American neighbors, to whom they are unnervingly indebted. As love develops between İrem and Dylan, Sinan makes a series of increasingly dangerous decisions that push him toward a betrayal that will change everyone’s lives forever.
The deep bonds among father, son, and daughter; the tension between honoring tradition and embracing personal freedom; the conflict between cultures and faiths; the regrets of age and the passions of youth–these are the timeless themes Alan Drew weaves into a brilliant fiction debut. (synopsis from barnesandnoble.com; slightly edited for length by moi).
Commentary: The most important (relevatory?) part of this novel was the relationship between the American boy Dylan and the Muslim Kurdish girl Irem–it proceeded quite realistically. I’ve been in Irem’s place before and I can understand a lot of the turmoil and thoughts running through her head, agreeing totally with her actions, while at the same time I could take an outsider’s view and try to reach through and yank her back from her accelerating path to the end. Alan Drew did a good job of portraying just what teenage infatuation is. I had a general disdain for Dylan and his stereotypical teenage-emo-angst, but if I were put in Irem’s place, I would not have known exactly what to do either. Her’s was an actual, real dilemma.
The cultural and societal information about the Turkish-Kurdish conflict was very informative–my only previous knowledge about the Kurds was that they were part of a holocaust-esque gas attack directed by the now deposed Saddam Hussein. My reading of Gardens of Water actually coincided with the current news that the Turkish government is moving against Kurds in Northern Iraq… and offered me some insight into that whole background.
The plot, characters, and overall historical and cultural background of the book was great, but at times, Drew’s style got a little overwrought and angsty, as if trying to wring emotion from every single last pronoun and adjective.
Good insight into Turkish and Kurdish history as well as Muslim culture–not so much for the emotional overtones.